Stone HarbororAvalon
Upscale island neighbors
Stone Harbor vs Avalon: Which Seven Mile Island Town Wins?
Sharing Seven Mile Island, Stone Harbor and Avalon are neighbors with similar upscale vibes but distinct personalities. Stone Harbor has a walkable downtown and a bird sanctuary, while Avalon offers pristine beaches and a slightly quieter atmosphere.
Quick Comparison
Notes
- Downtown: Stone Harbor's downtown is more walkable
- Beaches: Both have beautiful beaches
- Nature: Bird sanctuary is unique attraction
- Atmosphere: Different vibes for different preferences
Advertisement
Beaches
Both towns share the beautiful beaches of Seven Mile Island with the same $8 daily badge. Stone Harbor's beaches tend to be more crowded near the downtown area with a social, family atmosphere. Avalon's beaches are often quieter and less crowded, especially as you go north, with excellent dune preservation.
Activities & Attractions
Stone Harbor's unique attraction is the Stone Harbor Bird Sanctuary—a 21-acre heronry where herons, egrets, and ibises nest. The walkable downtown on 96th Street offers shopping and ice cream. Avalon has the community center, excellent fishing, and kayaking in the back bay.
Advertisement
Dining
Stone Harbor's 96th Street has a concentration of restaurants including Spiaggetta, and casual spots. Avalon has excellent upscale dining like Café Loren and the Sea Grill, though more spread out. Both towns have good BYOB options.
Accommodations
Both towns are primarily vacation rental destinations with beautiful beach houses ranging from modest to multimillion-dollar estates. Hotels are limited—most visitors rent houses for a week or longer. Stone Harbor has a few small inns.
Choose your stay
Check Stone Harbor staysCompare the full price and cancellation terms
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Choose your stay
Check Avalon staysCompare the full price and cancellation terms
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Getting There
Both towns are accessed via the same Garden State Parkway exits (10-13) and are about 2 hours from Philadelphia and 2.5+ hours from NYC. Parking in both towns requires permits in summer—plan accordingly.
The Verdict: Who Should Go Where?
Best for Families
Stone Harbor edges out with its walkable downtown, bird sanctuary, and slightly more kid-focused vibe.
Best for Couples
Avalon offers a quieter, more romantic atmosphere with excellent dining.
Best for Budget
Neither is budget-friendly—both are upscale destinations. Costs are similar.
Best for Nightlife
Neither has significant nightlife. Stone Harbor's downtown has a few bars. Both are quiet by 10 PM.
Best for Foodies
Both have excellent dining. Stone Harbor has more concentration downtown; Avalon has standout individual restaurants.
Overall Verdict
Stone Harbor for a more social, walkable family vacation. Avalon for a quieter, beach-focused retreat.
Vacation Rentals in Either Town
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Explore Stone Harbor
Explore Avalon
Stone Harbor vs Avalon FAQs
Can I walk between Stone Harbor and Avalon?
Yes! The towns share Seven Mile Island and blend together. You can walk or bike between them easily along the beach or streets.
Which town is more expensive?
Both are among the most expensive Jersey Shore destinations. Avalon has slightly higher average home values, but vacation rental costs are similar in both towns.
Are the beach badges the same?
No, each town sells its own badges. Stone Harbor badges work only in Stone Harbor, and Avalon badges only in Avalon. Both cost $8 daily. If you're staying for a week, consider a seasonal badge.
Do I need separate beach badges for Avalon and Stone Harbor?
Yes. Despite being on the same island, each town sells its own beach badges. An Avalon badge only works in Avalon; a Stone Harbor badge only in Stone Harbor. Both cost $8 daily. If visiting both, you'll need two badges.
Can I walk between Avalon and Stone Harbor?
Yes! The towns share Seven Mile Island and blend together. You can easily walk or bike between them along the beach or streets. Many visitors stay in one town and explore both during their vacation.
Which town is better for young kids?
Stone Harbor is slightly better for young kids due to the walkable downtown with ice cream shops (Springer's is famous), the bird sanctuary for nature education, and the more active beach scene near 96th Street. Both towns are excellent for families.