Harvey Cedars vs Holgate: LBI's Two Quiet Extremes
For those seeking LBI's quieter side, Harvey Cedars and Holgate offer escape from the island's busier towns. Harvey Cedars has surf culture and bayside sunsets, while Holgate borders a wildlife refuge.
Quick Comparison
Notes
- Wildlife: Holgate has exceptional birding
- Surfing: Harvey Cedars is a surf hub
🏖️ Beaches
Harvey Cedars has excellent surfing beaches and beautiful bayside access for sunset watching. Holgate beaches are even quieter, bordered by the Holgate Unit of Edwin B. Forsythe National Wildlife Refuge.
🎢 Activities & Attractions
Harvey Cedars offers surfing, bayside kayaking, and the Harvey Cedars Shellfish Company. Holgate is about nature—birding in the wildlife refuge, fishing, and total solitude.
🍽️ Dining
Harvey Cedars has the Harvey Cedars Shellfish Company (excellent seafood) and a few other spots. Holgate has virtually no commercial dining—bring your own or head to Beach Haven.
🏨 Accommodations
Both are vacation rental communities. Harvey Cedars has some of LBI's nicest homes. Holgate is smaller and even more secluded. No hotels in either.
Book Your Stay
Check AvailabilityFree cancellation on most stays • Verified guest reviews
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Book Your Stay
Check AvailabilityFree cancellation on most stays • Verified guest reviews
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
🚗 Getting There
Harvey Cedars is in the northern-central part of LBI. Holgate is at the very southern tip, beyond Beach Haven. Both accessed via Long Beach Boulevard.
The Verdict: Who Should Go Where?
Best for Families
Harvey Cedars is better for families with dining and surf lessons available. Holgate suits families seeking total quiet.
Best for Couples
Harvey Cedars for bayside sunsets and casual dining. Holgate for absolute solitude.
Best for Budget
Similar rental costs. Holgate requires more self-catering.
Best for Nightlife
Neither has nightlife. Harvey Cedars has a bar; Holgate has nothing.
Best for Foodies
Harvey Cedars wins with the Shellfish Company. Holgate has no restaurants.
🏆 Overall Verdict
Choose Harvey Cedars for surf culture and casual waterfront dining. Choose Holgate for maximum solitude and wildlife.
Find Vacation Rentals
Book beach houses, condos, and vacation homes in either destination.
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Explore Harvey Cedars
Beach badges, attractions, dining, and complete guide to Harvey Cedars.
Explore Holgate
Beach badges, attractions, dining, and complete guide to Holgate.
Harvey Cedars vs Holgate FAQs
More Town Comparisons
Ready to Plan Your Trip?
Check beach badge prices, find parking info, and explore all Jersey Shore towns.