Cape MayorSpring Lake
Two upscale Victorian towns compared
Cape May vs Spring Lake: Two Victorian Towns, One Winner
Two of New Jersey's most elegant Victorian beach towns offer refined escapes from the typical shore experience. Cape May enchants with its National Historic Landmark district and exceptional dining, while Spring Lake charms as the 'Irish Riviera' with its non-commercial boardwalk and pristine beaches.
Quick Comparison
Notes
- Beach Badges: Cape May is slightly more affordable
- Victorian Architecture: Cape May has the most preserved Victorian homes
- Fine Dining: Cape May is a culinary destination
- NYC Proximity: Spring Lake is much closer to NYC
- Boardwalk: Both have elegant walking paths
- Romantic Getaway: Both suit couples
Advertisement
Beaches
Cape May's beaches are pristine and less crowded, with the unique attraction of Cape May diamonds (quartz pebbles) at Sunset Beach. Spring Lake's 2-mile beach is backed by a beautiful non-commercial boardwalk with ocean views and benches. Both require badges and have excellent lifeguard coverage.
Activities & Attractions
Cape May offers whale and dolphin watching, the Cape May Lighthouse, Victorian trolley tours, birding at Cape May Point State Park, and the free Cape May Zoo. Spring Lake centers on relaxation: stroll the boardwalk, browse antique shops, kayak on the lake, or simply enjoy the Victorian architecture.
Advertisement
Dining
Cape May is a true foodie destination with restaurants like The Ebbitt Room, Washington Inn, and Peter Shields Inn. Spring Lake has respectable options like The Breakers and Whispers, but Cape May's culinary scene is significantly more developed.
Accommodations
Both towns specialize in romantic Victorian B&Bs. Cape May offers Congress Hall (America's oldest seaside resort), Virginia Hotel, and dozens of smaller inns. Spring Lake has The Breakers and Spring Lake Inn. Expect upscale prices at both destinations.
Choose your stay
Check Cape May staysCompare the full price and cancellation terms
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Choose your stay
Check Spring Lake staysCompare the full price and cancellation terms
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Getting There
Spring Lake is about 1 hour from NYC via the Garden State Parkway and has NJ Transit train access. Cape May is at the southern tip of New Jersey, about 2.5+ hours from NYC but offers the Cape May-Lewes Ferry to Delaware. Spring Lake wins for accessibility from North Jersey and NYC.
The Verdict: Who Should Go Where?
Best for Families
Cape May edges out with the zoo, lighthouse, and more activities for kids. Spring Lake works for quiet family beach days.
Best for Couples
Both are exceptional for romantic getaways. Cape May for foodies and sunset walks; Spring Lake for quiet elegance and easier access.
Best for Budget
Neither is budget-friendly. Cape May has cheaper badges but is further to drive. Spring Lake saves on travel from North Jersey.
Best for Nightlife
Neither has significant nightlife. Both are quiet, refined towns. Cape May has more bars; Spring Lake is essentially silent by 10 PM.
Best for Foodies
Cape May wins decisively with its acclaimed restaurant scene and BYOB culture.
Overall Verdict
Choose Cape May for exceptional dining, more activities, and the ultimate Victorian experience. Choose Spring Lake for easier NYC access and peaceful elegance.
Vacation Rentals in Either Town
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Explore Cape May
Explore Spring Lake
Cape May vs Spring Lake FAQs
Which town is better for a romantic weekend?
Both are excellent for romance. Cape May offers more dining options, sunset walks at Sunset Beach, and a wider variety of Victorian B&Bs. Spring Lake provides a quieter, more intimate experience with lakeside views and a beautiful boardwalk. Cape May is better for foodies; Spring Lake for those seeking serenity.
How far is Cape May from Spring Lake?
Cape May is about 1.5 hours south of Spring Lake via the Garden State Parkway (approximately 90 miles). They're at opposite ends of the Jersey Shore—Spring Lake in Monmouth County, Cape May at the southern tip.
Which town has better restaurants?
Cape May has a significantly better dining scene with acclaimed BYOB restaurants, farm-to-table options, and fine dining establishments. Spring Lake has good restaurants but fewer options overall.
Why is Spring Lake called the Irish Riviera?
Spring Lake earned the nickname due to its large Irish-American population and the grand estates reminiscent of European seaside resorts. Many visitors come from Irish-American families in the NYC area.
Which is better for a honeymoon?
Both are excellent honeymoon destinations. Cape May offers more activities and dining options; Spring Lake offers more seclusion and simple elegance. Personal preference determines the winner.
Can I take a train to either?
Spring Lake has NJ Transit train service (North Jersey Coast Line). Cape May has no direct train service—car or bus only.