Spring LakeorSea Girt
Upscale Monmouth County
Spring Lake vs Sea Girt: Which Upscale Shore Town Wins?
Two of Monmouth County's most prestigious beach communities sit side by side, offering refined alternatives to the busier shore towns. Spring Lake is known as the 'Irish Riviera' with Victorian architecture and a non-commercial boardwalk, while Sea Girt offers a quieter, more exclusive beach experience.
Quick Comparison
Notes
- Beach Badges: Same daily rate; Spring Lake's season pass is $5 less
- Boardwalk: Spring Lake has beautiful walking path
- Atmosphere: Both upscale but different vibes
- Dining: Spring Lake has more restaurant variety
- Crowds: Sea Girt is less crowded
- Architecture: Spring Lake has historic charm
Advertisement
Beaches
Spring Lake's beach stretches for 2 miles along a beautiful non-commercial boardwalk—no shops, no rides, just ocean views and benches. The beach itself is well-maintained with lifeguards. Sea Girt's beach is smaller and quieter, favored by those seeking a more private experience. Both require badges in summer.
Activities & Attractions
Spring Lake centers on relaxation: stroll the boardwalk, browse antique shops, visit St. Catharine's Church, or kayak on the lake. Sea Girt offers beach time and access to the Sea Girt Lighthouse (one of NJ's last operating lighthouses). Neither town has commercial entertainment—that's the appeal.
Advertisement
Dining
Spring Lake has a respectable restaurant scene including the Breakers on the Ocean and Whispers. Sea Girt has Parker House (a historic tavern) and Rod's Olde Irish Tavern, but most dining requires a short drive to Spring Lake or Manasquan.
Accommodations
Spring Lake is famous for its Victorian B&Bs and inns—The Breakers and Spring Lake Inn are local institutions. Sea Girt has fewer options, mostly vacation rentals. Both towns are expensive—these are some of the priciest shore communities.
Choose your stay
Check Spring Lake staysCompare the full price and cancellation terms
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Choose your stay
Check Sea Girt staysCompare the full price and cancellation terms
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Getting There
Both are about 1 hour from NYC via the Garden State Parkway. Spring Lake has a NJ Transit station (North Jersey Coast Line) making it accessible without a car. Sea Girt requires driving. Parking is metered in both towns during summer.
The Verdict: Who Should Go Where?
Best for Families
Spring Lake is better for families wanting beach plus walkable town. Sea Girt suits families seeking quiet beach days.
Best for Couples
Spring Lake wins for couples with its romantic B&Bs, fine dining, and evening boardwalk strolls.
Best for Budget
Neither is budget-friendly. Both are among the most expensive shore towns. Spring Lake has a slightly cheaper season badge.
Best for Nightlife
Neither has nightlife. Both are quiet by 9 PM. Head to Belmar or Asbury Park for bars.
Best for Foodies
Spring Lake has more dining options, though both are limited compared to Cape May or Asbury Park.
Overall Verdict
Spring Lake for Victorian charm, walkable town, and better amenities. Sea Girt for maximum quiet and exclusivity.
Vacation Rentals in Either Town
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Explore Spring Lake
Explore Sea Girt
Spring Lake vs Sea Girt FAQs
Can I walk between Spring Lake and Sea Girt?
Yes! The towns border each other. You can walk along the beach from one to the other (with badges for each). Spring Lake's boardwalk ends at the Sea Girt border.
Which town is more expensive?
Both are among the most expensive Jersey Shore destinations. Sea Girt has slightly higher property values on average, but visitor costs are similar. Daily badges are $12 in both towns, and Spring Lake's season pass is $5 cheaper.
Is there a train to Sea Girt?
No direct train. Spring Lake has a NJ Transit station on the North Jersey Coast Line. From Spring Lake station, Sea Girt is about a 10-minute drive or 30-minute walk.