Highlands vs Atlantic Highlands: Bayshore Twins Compared
These adjacent bayshore communities share similar names but offer distinct experiences. Highlands is home to Twin Lights and legendary clam bars, while Atlantic Highlands has the NYC ferry and a charming downtown. Both provide Sandy Hook access.
Quick Comparison
Notes
- Historic Sites: Twin Lights is iconic
- NYC Access: Direct ferry to Manhattan
- Dining: Bahrs Landing is famous
🏖️ Beaches
Neither has traditional ocean beaches—both are on Sandy Hook Bay. Highlands has small bay beaches good for calm water activities. Atlantic Highlands has similar bay access. Both serve as gateways to Sandy Hook's ocean beaches, which are free with a parking fee.
🎢 Activities & Attractions
Highlands features Twin Lights Historic Site with spectacular views and the first electric lighthouse in America. Clam bars and waterfront dining are the draw. Atlantic Highlands has the Seastreak ferry to NYC, a walkable downtown, and the Henry Hudson Trail.
🍽️ Dining
Highlands is famous for Bahrs Landing (since 1917), The Clam Hut, and Inlet Cafe—classic seafood in waterfront settings. Atlantic Highlands has Copper Canyon, On the Deck, and other downtown restaurants with a more varied scene.
🏨 Accommodations
Neither has major hotels. Vacation rentals and B&Bs serve both communities. Many visitors stay elsewhere and day trip to these bayshore towns.
🚗 Getting There
Both are about 1 hour from NYC by car. Atlantic Highlands has the Seastreak ferry with direct service to Manhattan (40 minutes). NJ Transit buses serve both areas.
The Verdict: Who Should Go Where?
Best for Families
Both work for families seeking Sandy Hook access. Atlantic Highlands has more walkable dining options.
Best for Couples
Highlands for romantic seafood dinners; Atlantic Highlands for ferry adventures and downtown strolls.
Best for Budget
Similar costs. Both are more affordable than oceanfront towns.
Best for Nightlife
Neither has significant nightlife. Both are quiet by evening.
Best for Foodies
Highlands wins for seafood lovers with its legendary clam bars. Atlantic Highlands has more variety.
🏆 Overall Verdict
Choose Highlands for Twin Lights and legendary seafood. Choose Atlantic Highlands for NYC ferry access and downtown charm.
Find Vacation Rentals
Book beach houses, condos, and vacation homes in either destination.
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Explore Highlands
Beach badges, attractions, dining, and complete guide to Highlands.
Explore Atlantic Highlands
Beach badges, attractions, dining, and complete guide to Atlantic Highlands.
Highlands vs Atlantic Highlands FAQs
More Town Comparisons
Ready to Plan Your Trip?
Check beach badge prices, find parking info, and explore all Jersey Shore towns.