Barnegat Light vs Beach Haven: LBI North vs South
Long Beach Island's northern and southern tips offer dramatically different experiences. Barnegat Light is quiet with the iconic lighthouse, while Beach Haven brings Fantasy Island fun and a more active downtown.
Quick Comparison
Notes
- Attractions: Different appeals
- Crowds: For those seeking solitude
- Fishing: Barnegat is the fishing capital
🏖️ Beaches
Barnegat Light's beaches are quieter with fewer people and more natural beauty. The jetty area near the lighthouse is popular for fishing and photography. Beach Haven has wider, more active beaches with more families and facilities.
🎢 Activities & Attractions
Barnegat Light centers on the lighthouse (217 steps, spectacular views) and jetty fishing. It's a nature lover's paradise. Beach Haven has Fantasy Island amusement park, mini golf, shops on Bay Avenue, and the Long Beach Island Foundation arts center.
🍽️ Dining
Barnegat Light has limited dining—Kubel's is the local favorite. Beach Haven has many more options: The Chicken or the Egg, Black Whale, Buckalew's, and dozens more along Bay Avenue.
🏨 Accommodations
Both rely on vacation rentals. Barnegat Light has smaller, often older beach cottages. Beach Haven has more variety including some motels and the Engleside Inn.
🚗 Getting There
Both are accessed via Route 72 to LBI. Beach Haven is at the southern tip, Barnegat Light at the northern tip. Long Beach Boulevard connects all LBI towns—about 20 minutes end to end.
The Verdict: Who Should Go Where?
Best for Families
Beach Haven wins for families with Fantasy Island and more activities. Barnegat Light suits families wanting quiet beach time.
Best for Couples
Barnegat Light for romantic lighthouse sunsets and solitude. Beach Haven for couples who enjoy some activity.
Best for Budget
Similar costs—LBI is generally affordable with free beaches.
Best for Nightlife
Beach Haven has a few bars. Barnegat Light is very quiet after dark.
Best for Foodies
Beach Haven has significantly more dining options and variety.
🏆 Overall Verdict
Choose Barnegat Light for the lighthouse, fishing, and quiet. Choose Beach Haven for activities, dining, and family fun.
Find Vacation Rentals
Book beach houses, condos, and vacation homes in either destination.
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Explore Barnegat Light
Beach badges, attractions, dining, and complete guide to Barnegat Light.
Explore Beach Haven
Beach badges, attractions, dining, and complete guide to Beach Haven.
Barnegat Light vs Beach Haven FAQs
More Town Comparisons
Ready to Plan Your Trip?
Check beach badge prices, find parking info, and explore all Jersey Shore towns.