Jersey ShoreGUIDE

Spring Lake Real Estate

Monmouth County Housing Market Is Heating Up

$1.8MMedian Price
13Listings
41Days on Market

Spring Lake Housing Market

Spring Lake is called the Irish Riviera, a nickname that came from decades of New York and New Jersey Irish-American families buying summer homes that eventually became permanent residences and multi-generational properties. No boardwalk by design. A quiet lake, parks, and private beach access restricted to residents. Victorian homes on the ocean blocks regularly sell above $3 million, while inland properties provide a lower entry point into one of the more stable shore markets in Monmouth County. The typical buyer is affluent Tri-State Area: Manhattan or suburban NJ families who want a shore house that functions as a retreat. Spring Lake does not have much of a rental market because most owners hold for personal use. If you want a property that generates summer income, you will find less competition here than in Ocean City. The buyer pool you are competing against for purchase, though, is still strong and steady.

Summer is peak season for shore real estate activity. Expect competition for beachfront and ocean-view properties as seasonal buyers are most active.

Price Trends (24 Months)

$667K$1.6M$2.5M$3.5M$4.4MMay '24Sep '24Jan '25May '25Sep '25Jan '26Apr '26
Median List Price
Latest: $1.8M

Current Market Snapshot

Median Price
$1.79M
-29.2%YoY
Active Listings
13
Days on Market
41
Monthly Change
-37.4%

Compared to Monmouth County

ZIP Median Price
$1.8M
County Median
$814K
Difference
+119.7%above county avg

Market Health Indicators

Price Trend
-29.2%
Days on Market
41 days
Inventory
13

About Spring Lake

Spring Lake is a shore community in Monmouth County. Learn more about beaches, attractions, dining, and events.

Spring Lake

Try Spring Lake Before You Buy

Rent a vacation home to experience the neighborhood before committing β€” or book a hotel for a scouting trip.

Plan Your Trip to Spring Lake, NJ

Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more

Investment Potential

Investment Calculator

Estimate your potential returns if you rent out your Spring Lake property during summer months.

$
10%$357K50%
$

Peak summer week rate

4 wks20 wks

Annual Summary

Gross Rental Income$64,800
Est. Expenses (30%)-$19,440
Net Rental Income$45,360
Annual Mortgage-$114,134
Property Tax (est.)-$32,166
Annual Cash Flow$-100,940
Cap Rate
0.7%
Cash-on-Cash
-28.2%

Investment Outlook

Challenging as pure investment. Negative cash flow means you would need other income or appreciation to justify. Better suited as a vacation home with some rental offset.

* Estimates only. Consult a financial advisor and research local rental regulations. Expenses estimate includes insurance, maintenance, management, and vacancy.

Nearby ZIP Codes

Spring Lake Market Updates

Get monthly housing insights for this area.

What interests you? (optional)

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Spring Lake Real Estate FAQs

Why is Spring Lake called the Irish Riviera?
The nickname dates to the late 19th and early 20th centuries when Irish-American families from New York and New Jersey began buying summer homes in Spring Lake. The community built strong social ties around churches, summer events, and multi-generational homeownership. The Irish-American identity remains part of the town's culture.
Does Spring Lake have public beach access?
Spring Lake beach is restricted to residents and their guests. This is intentional and part of the town's identity. Non-residents cannot purchase beach badges, which keeps crowds manageable and supports property values. It is a meaningful difference from most Monmouth County shore towns.
What types of homes are available in Spring Lake?
Spring Lake has a high concentration of Victorian and Colonial-style homes, particularly on the ocean and lake blocks. Many are historic, well-maintained, and substantial in size. Newer construction exists but is less common. Prices range from around $1M for inland smaller homes to well above $3M on ocean blocks.
Is Spring Lake good for rental income?
Not primarily. Most owners in Spring Lake hold properties for personal use and do not rent. If you want vacation rental income, Ocean City or Wildwood are better fits. The absence of a rental-heavy culture is part of the neighborhood's appeal for buyers who want a stable, community-oriented environment.
How does Spring Lake compare to Sea Girt?
Spring Lake and Sea Girt (the borough just south) are closely comparable in character and price. Both have private beach access, quiet residential character, and similar buyer demographics. Spring Lake is somewhat larger with more amenities. Sea Girt is smaller and quieter, with the added attraction of a state marina.