Skip to main content
Jersey ShoreGUIDE

Best Bakeries at the Jersey Shore

Fresh bread, pastries, donuts, and sweet treats at the Jersey Shore's finest bakeries. From Italian pastry shops to beachside donut stands.

15Bakeries
15+Donut Shops
20+Shore Towns

Why Visit Shore Bakeries

Jersey Shore Bakery Tradition

The Jersey Shore has a rich bakery tradition dating back generations, shaped by Italian immigrants who brought Old World recipes to shore towns from Asbury Park to Cape May. Today, that tradition lives on in family-owned bakeries serving authentic cannoli, sfogliatelle, and ricotta pie.

Beyond the Italian classics, you'll find everything from artisan sourdough and fresh-baked bagels to whimsical beach-themed donuts and crumb cakes. Many shore bakeries have been perfecting their recipes for decades.

Beach donuts, celebration cakes and morning pastries.

Monmouth County

Italian classics and artisan bakes

#1 Pick

Delicious Orchards

colts-neck•Route 34
$$

Farm market with incredible baked goods and famous apple cider donuts.

Famous For: Apple Cider Donuts
Apple cider donutsFresh piesFarm marketSeasonal treats
Outdoor
#2 Pick

Strollo's Lighthouse

Long Branch•Pier Village
$

Long Branch institution serving Italian ice and gelato since 1987.

Famous For: Italian Ice
Italian iceGelatoPier Village locationFamily favorite
Outdoor

Ocean County

Island bakeries and beach treats

#1 Pick

Ob-Co's Donuts

Toms River•Fischer Boulevard
$

Old-school donut shop beloved for classic crumb donuts and friendly service.

Famous For: Crumb Donuts
Crumb donutsClassic flavorsCash onlyMorning lines
#2 Pick

Crust & Crumb

Beach Haven•Bay Village
$$

LBI's artisan bakery with fresh sourdough, pastries, and breakfast sandwiches.

Famous For: Sourdough Bread
Fresh sourdoughPastriesBreakfast sandwichesCoffee
Outdoor
#3 Pick

Uncle Will's Pancake House

Beach Haven•Long Beach Boulevard
$$

Beloved LBI breakfast spot with famous sticky buns and fresh-baked treats.

Famous For: Sticky Buns
Sticky bunsPancakesLBI institutionLines worth it

Mueller's Bakery

Bay Head•Bridge Avenue
$$

Bay Head bakery since 1890 with crumb cake and pastries.

Famous For: Crumb Cake
Famous crumb cakeGerman pastriesHistoricCash only
Early Hours

The Bagel Shack

$

LBI go-to for fresh bagels, cream cheese, and breakfast sandwiches.

Everything Bagel
Fresh bagelsCream cheese varieties

Advertisement

Atlantic County

Shore classics and Italian favorites

#1 Pick

Formica Bros. Bakery

Atlantic City•Ducktown
$

Atlantic City institution since 1919, famous for Italian bread and tomato pie.

Famous For: Tomato Pie
Since 1919Tomato pieItalian breadHistoric
#2 Pick

Rando's Bakery

Margate•Ventnor Avenue
$$

Family bakery with authentic Italian pastries and custom cakes.

Famous For: Cannoli
Authentic cannoliCustom cakesItalian cookiesFamily-owned
#3 Pick

Casel's Marketplace

Margate•Ventnor Avenue
$$

Upscale market with excellent fresh-baked bread and prepared foods.

Famous For: Fresh Bread
Fresh breadPrepared foodsQuality ingredientsUpscale market

Cape May County

Victorian treats and boardwalk sweets

#1 Pick

Brown's Restaurant

Ocean City•Boardwalk
$

Ocean City boardwalk legend serving hot donuts since 1930.

Famous For: Hot Donuts
Since 1930Hot fresh donutsBoardwalk locationWatch them made
Outdoor
#2 Pick

Oves Restaurant

Ocean City•9th Street
$$

Family restaurant famous for incredible sticky buns and breakfast.

Famous For: Sticky Buns
Famous sticky bunsFull breakfastFamily-ownedCash only
#3 Pick

Kohler's Bakery

Avalon•21st Street
$$

Avalon bakery on 21st Street serving donuts and baked goods.

Famous For: Crumb Cake
Fresh pastries

Douglass Fudge

Wildwood•Boardwalk
$$

Wildwood boardwalk tradition serving homemade fudge and candies.

Famous For: Chocolate Fudge
Homemade fudgeBoardwalk locationWatch it madeShore tradition
Outdoor

Laura's Fudge

$$

Family-owned fudge shop on the Wildwood boardwalk since 1926.

Peanut Butter Fudge
Since 1926Multiple flavors

Tips

Bakery Tips

Arrive Early

Arrive before 9am for the best selection, especially on weekends.

Pre-Order for Holidays

Planning a special occasion?

Beach Breakfast

Grab donuts or pastries to-go and enjoy breakfast on the beach. Perfect beach day fuel.

Italian Tradition

Jersey Shore has amazing Italian bakeries with cannoli, sfogliatelle, and ricotta pie—don't miss them!

Advertisement

FAQ

What are the best bakeries for donuts at the Jersey Shore?

Brown's on the Ocean City boardwalk has made hot donuts since 1930. Ob-Co's in Toms River has amazing crumb donuts. Delicious Orchards' apple cider donuts are also must-tries.

Where can I find authentic Italian pastries at the shore?

Formica Bros. in Atlantic City (since 1919) is famous for Italian bread and tomato pie. Rando's in Margate serves authentic Italian cookies and pastries.

Which shore bakeries have the best crumb cake?

Mueller's Bakery in Bay Head makes crumb cake. Kohler's in Avalon also makes a great version.

Do I need to arrive early at shore bakeries?

Yes! Ob-Co's donuts are often gone by mid-morning. Aim to arrive before 9am for the best selection.

Can I order custom cakes at shore bakeries?

Many shore bakeries do custom cakes—Rando's and Kohler's are popular choices.

Are there gluten-free or vegan options?

Options are limited but growing. Some bakeries offer gluten-free items—call ahead to check. Artisan bakeries like Crust & Crumb may have options. Most traditional Italian bakeries don't have GF/vegan items.

Related Guides

Where to eat at the Shore, all year

A short series on where to eat, then a Thursday email with the weekend ahead and a planning guide on the 1st.

What interests you? (optional)

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.