Dining in Historic Smithville
Restaurants, seafood, and local favorites in Historic Smithville, New Jersey.
american
Historic Smithville Inn
$$$Fine dining since 1787 in a historic colonial building. Elegant American cuisine with seasonal menus.
Must try: Prime rib or seasonal specials
Fred and Ethel's Lantern Light Tavern
$$Named after Smithville's founders. Casual bar and grill with indoor/outdoor seating, live weekend entertainment, and 8 TVs for sports.
Must try: Homemade French onion soup
cafe
Smithville Bakery
$Famous for homemade doughnuts, custom pies and cakes, and full breakfast menu starting at 7:00 a.m.
Must try: Homemade doughnuts
Colonial Coffee Cafe
$Coffee shop serving specialty drinks, pastries, and light fare. An easy break between shops.
Must try: Specialty latte
italian
Costello's Italian Ristorante
$$Traditional Italian cuisine inside the village. Family-friendly atmosphere with classic dishes.
Must try: Pasta dishes
casual
Greek Bites
$Quick-service Greek favorites including gyros, souvlaki, and Mediterranean salads.
Must try: Gyro platter
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Advertisement
Best Restaurants in Historic Smithville
Explore our lists of top dining spots in Historic Smithville.
More in Historic Smithville
Make a plan for your actual dates
Confirm the kitchen hours, dining room, menu and reservation terms for the meal you want. Check drinks policy, dietary needs and access directly with the restaurant.
Fall outings →
Start with dated festivals and outdoor plans; confirm the operator schedule and keep an indoor alternative.
Holiday weekends →
Check the specific event date, ticket terms and dining service before choosing an overnight stay.
Winter and spring →
Build around an indoor activity or meal, then add a coastal walk if conditions allow.
Next summer →
Save a town shortlist and check beach access, group needs and complete stay quotes as dates firm up.
Consider a nearby meal
These neighboring town guides have existing listings. Check the actual venue schedule and your travel arrangements.
Keep the details before you reserve
Compare the complete activity cost
Include the number of tickets, required equipment, parking and any booking charge. Compare packages only when their actual inclusions fit your visit.
Keep the weather terms
Read cancellation deadlines, weather postponement and refund rules before paying. Choose an indoor backup with a confirmed schedule.
Keep your Historic Smithville plans moving
Get the free Shore Insider Guide after confirming, followed by tips for your selected interests. Change your preferences or unsubscribe from any email.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Advertisement