Best Restaurants in Historic Smithville
6 restaurants in this atlantic County beach town
Browse the top restaurants in smithville with pricing, features, and local tips to help you choose.
Top 6 Restaurants
Historic Smithville Inn
$$$Fine dining since 1787 in a historic colonial building. Voted "Best Off-Shore Restaurant." Elegant American cuisine with seasonal menus.
Costello's Italian Ristorante
$$Traditional Italian cuisine in the heart of the village. Family-friendly atmosphere with classic dishes.
Fred and Ethel's Lantern Light Tavern
$$Named after Smithville's founders. Casual bar and grill with indoor/outdoor seating, live weekend entertainment, and 8 TVs for sports.
Colonial Coffee Cafe
$Coffee shop serving specialty drinks, pastries, and light fare. Perfect for a break between shopping.
Greek Bites
$Quick-service Greek favorites including gyros, souvlaki, and Mediterranean salads.
Smithville Bakery
$Famous for homemade doughnuts, custom pies and cakes, and full breakfast menu starting at 7:00 a.m.
Our Top Picks Reviewed
Best Overall: Historic Smithville Inn
Historic Smithville Inn stands out as our top pick for restaurants in Historic Smithville.Fine dining since 1787 in a historic colonial building. Voted "Best Off-Shore Restaurant." Elegant American cuisine with seasonal menus. At $$$ pricing, it delivers excellent value for the quality. Notable features include historic building, fine dining, colonial atmosphere. Specializing in american and fine-dining, this spot is perfect for both locals and visitors.
Best Value: Fred and Ethel's Lantern Light Tavern
Fred and Ethel's Lantern Light Tavern delivers solid quality at $$ pricing.Named after Smithville's founders. Casual bar and grill with indoor/outdoor seating, live weekend entertainment, and 8 TVs for sports. A reliable pick for families and groups on a set budget.
Best for Special Occasions: Costello's Italian Ristorante
For a nicer night out in Historic Smithville, Costello's Italian Ristorante is a strong choice.Traditional Italian cuisine in the heart of the village. Family-friendly atmosphere with classic dishes. The quality and atmosphere hold up well at this price level.
What to Know Before You Go
The restaurants scene in Historic Smithville varies by season. During peak summer months (June through August), wait times at popular spots can exceed an hour, especially on weekend evenings. We recommend making reservations at least a week in advance for weekend dining. Off-season visitors (September through May) will find it much easier to secure tables, and many establishments offer seasonal specials and promotions.
Price-wise, expect to spend between $15-30 per person at $ spots, $30-50 at $$ establishments, $50-80 at $$$ venues, and $80+ at $$$$ fine dining locations. Most Historic Smithville restaurants are BYOB-friendly, which can significantly reduce your total bill if you bring your own wine or beer.
Quick Comparison
| Name | Price | Best For | Highlights |
|---|---|---|---|
| Historic Smithville Inn | $$$ | Date Night | historic building, fine dining |
| Costello's Italian Ristorante | $$ | Families & Groups | Italian, family-friendly |
| Fred and Ethel's Lantern Light Tavern | $$ | Families & Groups | live music, outdoor seating |
| Colonial Coffee Cafe | $ | Budget-Conscious | coffee, pastries |
| Greek Bites | $ | Budget-Conscious | quick service, Greek |
Planning Your Visit to Historic Smithville?
Check out our complete guide to Historic Smithville with beaches, events, parking info, and more.
View Historic Smithville Guide →Historic Smithville is a charming, shopping Atlantic County beach town about 2hr from New York City. Parking, beach badges, events, and the full picture beyond restaurants are in the complete Historic Smithville guide.