Monmouth County vs Cape May County
Real Estate Market Comparison
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Metric | Monmouth County | Cape May County | Better For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Median Price | $814K✓ | $924K | Affordability |
| YoY Price Change | -4.8%✓ | +8.8% | Buyers (cooling) |
| Active Listings | 1,306✓ | 888 | More Options |
| Days on Market | 33 days | 57 days✓ | Negotiation |
| ZIP Codes | 17✓ | 9 | Variety |
24-Month Price Trends
Monmouth County
Median List Price
Latest: $814K
Cape May County
Median List Price
Latest: $924K
Which County Should You Choose?
Monmouth County
- ✓$111K lower median price
- ✓418 more active listings
- ✓Prices cooling faster (better for buyers)
- ✓More coastal communities (17 ZIP codes)
Cape May County
- ✓More time to negotiate (57 days avg)
- ✓9 shore towns to explore
Not Sure Yet? Try Before You Buy
Rent a vacation home in both counties to experience the neighborhoods and lifestyle before making your decision.
Plan your next Shore trip
Start with the free Shore Insider Guide — beach access, parking, packing and comparing your stay. Then a free email every Thursday with the weekend ahead, and a planning guide on the 1st.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.