Skip to main content
Jersey ShoreGUIDE

🍝 Italian Restaurants

in Cape May

Looking for italian in Cape May? The shore town has 7 spots serving pasta, pizza, and authentic italian cuisine. Romans Pizza House-N Cape May is a local favorite.

Before you go to a restaurant in Cape May

Recorded menus, hours and price bands are starting points. Confirm your exact date with the operator, especially outside summer.

  • Check the current menu, kitchen hours and whether your group needs a reservation.
  • Confirm payment methods, the total including tax and service charges, and any reservation deposit or cancellation terms.
  • For mobility needs, ask about the route from parking to the table and restroom; for dietary needs, discuss preparation with the kitchen.
  • Check whether outdoor seating is operating and choose an indoor backup. A seasonal listing does not confirm an opening date.

Price Range

7 moderate

Dining Tip

Italian restaurants at the shore often have generous portions. Consider sharing a pasta dish.

7 Italian Restaurants in Cape May

Romans Pizza House-N Cape May

$$

Pizza house serving North Cape May.

italian

Rita's Italian Ice-Frozen

$$

Italian ice and frozen custard chain stop.

italian

Jojo Pizza

$$

Jojo turns out pies and slices.

italian

Jake's Pizza Co

$$

Pizza company baking pies in Cape May.

italian

Italian Villa Pizzeria-Restaurant

$$

Pizzeria-restaurant hybrid with Italian plates.

italian

Italian Affair Pizza & Pasta

$$

Pizza and pasta, Italian all the way.

italian

Iccara Italian Bistro

$$

Italian bistro plating pastas.

italian

Keep planning your shore meals

Get the free Shore Insider Guide plus dining and trip planning emails throughout the year.

What interests you? (optional)

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

More Dining in Cape May

Italian Restaurants at Other Shore Towns

Tips for Italian Dining in Cape May

Summer reservations: Book 1-2 weeks ahead for weekend dinners, especially July-August.

BYOB advantage: Many Cape May restaurants are BYOB—bring your own wine and save.

Off-peak savings: Early bird specials (5-6pm) often include price breaks.

Dress code: Most italian spots are casual—flip flops usually fine.

People Also Search For

Italian Dining FAQs

Stay in Cape May

Book accommodations near the best italian restaurants in Cape May.

Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more