Skip to main content
Jersey ShoreGUIDE

American Restaurants

in Cape May

Looking for american in Cape May? The shore town has 19 spots serving classic american comfort food and contemporary dishes. The Ebbitt Room is a local favorite.

Price Range

3 upscale, 1 mid-high, 15 moderate

Dining Tip

Many American restaurants in Cape May offer happy hour specials. Check for early bird dinner deals.

19 American Restaurants in Cape May

The Ebbitt Room

$$$$Reservations

Chef Jason Hanin. Seasonal tasting menus use Cape May scallops and Beach Plum Farm ingredients. Porch dining with live piano.

fine diningamerican

Must Try: Seasonal tasting menu

  • ✓farm-to-table
  • ✓live piano
  • ✓porch dining
Virginia Hotel, 25 Jackson Street

Washington Inn

$$$$Reservations

Wine list and fireside dining in an 1840 plantation-style building. Baked escargot and seafood risotto.

fine diningamerican

Must Try: Baked escargot

  • ✓extensive wine list
  • ✓historic building
  • ✓fireside dining
801 Washington Street

Peter Shields Inn

$$$$Reservations

Ocean views from a 1907 Georgian Revival building. NOTE: No longer BYOB as of January 1, 2025 ($40 corkage fee).

fine diningamerican

Must Try: Chef's tasting menu

  • ✓ocean views
  • ✓historic inn
1301 Beach Avenue

410 Bank Street

$$$SeasonalReservations

Chef Sing's Creole-Caribbean cuisine in a vine-covered 1840 carriage house. BYOB. Seasonal closure in winter.

seafoodamerican

Must Try: Caribbean specialties

  • ✓Creole-Caribbean
  • ✓BYOB
  • ✓historic carriage house

Phinney's Pub

$$

Pub drinks and casual fare.

american

Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

$$

Restaurant inside the Peter Shields Inn.

american

Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar

$$

Oysters in the name, American menu on the table.

american

Oceanview Restaurant

$$

American meals with an ocean-view name.

american

Ocean View Family Restaurant

$$

Family restaurant serving Ocean View.

american

Mermaids Restaurant

$$

Mermaids serves American dishes in Cape May.

american

Mayer's Tavern

$$

Tavern standbys — drinks and American food.

american

Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar

$$

American restaurant and bar in Cape May.

american

Lucky Bones Back Water Grille

$$

Backwater grille plating American, seafood-leaning fare.

american

Harry's Ocean Bar & Grille

$$

Harry's pairs a bar with American grille fare.

american

King Edward Bar

$$

King Edward Bar pours drinks in Cape May.

american

Lucky Bones Backwater Grille

$$

Marina-side praise for fried oysters and Cape May Double IPA craft beer. Family-friendly with outdoor seating.

americanbar grill

Must Try: Fried oysters

  • ✓waterfront
  • ✓happy hour
  • ✓kid-friendly
  • ✓outdoor seating

The Mad Batter

$$

Operating since 1976 in Victorian Carroll Villa Hotel. Orange & Almond French Toast and famous Bloody Marys. Polarizes visitors—beloved for food, criticized for "supercilious" service. 45-60 minute weekend waits.

americancafe

Must Try: Orange & Almond French Toast

  • ✓Victorian setting
  • ✓breakfast famous
  • ✓Bloody Marys
19 Jackson Street

George's Place

$$

"If Nancy Meyers opened a Greek diner" atmosphere. Tiramisu waffles and flaming Saganaki draw crowds.

americancafe

Must Try: Tiramisu waffles or flaming Saganaki

  • ✓breakfast
  • ✓Greek touches
  • ✓Instagram-worthy
Beach Avenue

The Blue Pig Tavern

$$

Historic tavern at Congress Hall serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Farm-to-table focus with Beach Plum Farm ingredients.

americancasual

Must Try: Buttermilk pancakes

  • ✓historic
  • ✓breakfast
  • ✓farm-to-table
  • ✓patio

Advertisement

Where to eat at the Shore, all year

A short series on where to eat, then a Thursday email with the weekend ahead and a planning guide on the 1st.

What interests you? (optional)

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

More Dining in Cape May

American Restaurants at Other Shore Towns

BYOB American in Cape May

1 of these 19 listings is marked BYOB. Confirm the policy with the restaurant before you go.

People Also Search For

American Dining FAQs

Which american restaurants can I research in Cape May?

This directory records 19 matching listings, including The Ebbitt Room, Washington Inn, Peter Shields Inn. Confirm the current menu and opening date directly.

Do I need reservations in Cape May?

4 matching listings record a reservation option. Check the operator’s booking calendar, group rules, deposits and cancellation terms; availability is not supplied by this directory.

How should I budget for american in Cape May?

The recorded price symbols are comparison bands. Use the current menu and include drinks, tax, gratuity and any disclosed charges to calculate your party’s actual total.

Can I bring wine or beer to dinner in Cape May?

1 matching listings record BYOB as a feature. Confirm the current operator policy and local rules before bringing wine or beer. An unlicensed BYOB arrangement does not permit spirits under NJ ABC guidance.

Are these restaurants open outside summer?

1 matching listings are marked seasonal. An unmarked listing does not confirm year-round opening. Verify your exact date, kitchen hours and any seasonal break directly with the operator.

Can I request outdoor seating?

2 matching listings record an outdoor feature. Confirm whether it is operating on your date, how tables are allocated and what indoor alternative is available if weather changes.

How do I choose a family meal?

Ask about children’s menu options, seating and preparation for dietary needs. Price level, cuisine and an early service time do not establish suitability for your family.

Can I walk to dinner from the beach?

Check the exact restaurant address and route from your beach or accommodation. Review distance, crossings, lighting and any access needs; this directory does not establish a walkable route for every listing.

Stay in Cape May

Book accommodations near the best american restaurants in Cape May.

Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more