Dining in Ortley Beach
Restaurants, seafood, and local favorites in Ortley Beach, New Jersey.
4Restaurants
4Cuisines
american
Hemingway's Cafe
$$Local favorite for breakfast and lunch. Casual beachy atmosphere.
Must try: Pancakes
cafecasuallocal favorite
🌞 Seasonal hours
casual
Barnacle Bill's
$Grab snacks and treats at this iconic mini golf spot. Ice cream, snacks, and refreshments after a round.
Must try: Ice cream after mini golf
boardwalkice creamfamily-friendly
🌞 Seasonal hours
boardwalk
Nearby Seaside Heights Dining
$$Seaside Heights (5 min south) offers the full boardwalk dining experience including Midway Steak House, Maruca's Tomato Pies, and Spicy Cantina.
Must try: Maruca's tomato pie or Midway cheeseballs
boardwalk optionsvarietynearby
seafood
Nearby Lavallette Dining
$$Lavallette (5 min north) offers Crab's Claw Inn for waterfront seafood and Carluccio's for coal-fired pizza.
Must try: Crab's Claw Inn seafood
seafoodpizzanearby
📞 Reservations recommended
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Best Restaurants in Ortley Beach
Explore our curated lists of top dining spots in Ortley Beach.