The Mainstay Inn
Cape May
Italianate Victorian B&B from 1872 with original furnishings and a grand veranda.
About The Mainstay Inn
The Mainstay Inn is an architectural treasure among Cape May's Victorian landmarks. Built in 1872, this Italianate villa features original furnishings, 14-foot ceilings, ornate plasterwork, and a grand veranda overlooking the gardens. The inn transports guests to the golden age of Cape May's resort era.
Highlights
Amenities & Features
Room Types
Insider Tip
Take a guided house tour to appreciate the architectural details. The veranda is perfect for afternoon relaxation.
Best For
Book Your Stay
Nightly rates from
$185 - $385
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Property Info
- Beach Access
- 5-min-walk
- Check-in / Check-out
- Check-in: 3:00 PMCheck-out: 11:00 AM
- Parking
- street
- Address
- 635 Columbia Avenue, Cape May, NJ 08204
- Phone
- 609-884-8690
- Established
- 1872
Dining in Cape May
View All Seafood →The Lobster House
$$$Massive waterfront complex. Fresh-off-the-boat seafood.
The Ebbitt Room
$$$$Cape May fine dining at Virginia Hotel. Farm-to-table excellence.
410 Bank Street
$$$$Romantic garden setting. French-influenced coastal cuisine.
Compare your Cape May stay, in any season
Build a shortlist for your dates, check the complete price, and choose the room setup and terms that fit your trip.
Same trip, same group
Use the same dates and all travelers. Include every room or rental your group needs in the quoted stay price.
Complete the total
Add taxes, required fees, and parking only when they are not already in the quote. Enter zero for an included cost; leave an unknown cost blank until you confirm it.
Check what will be open
Confirm the property’s operating dates and the specific amenities you need. Ask about pools, kitchens, beach access, and nearby services for your travel dates.
Read the reservation terms
Compare minimum stays, deposits, cancellation deadlines, pet rules, and occupancy limits before paying. Ask how a refundable deposit differs from a required charge.
Search the same dates and group size, then bring the complete quotes to the comparison tool.
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Keep your stay shortlist moving
Get the free Shore Insider Guide after confirming, followed by stay-comparison and seasonal planning tips. Change your interests or unsubscribe from any email.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
More Places to Stay
Congress Hall
Cape May
America's oldest seaside resort. Victorian elegance meets modern luxury.
Icona Diamond Beach
Wildwood Crest
Luxury oceanfront resort on pristine Wildwood Crest beach.
The Reeds at Shelter Haven
Stone Harbor
Intimate bayside boutique with well-regarded restaurant and harbor views.