Mahi Fishing Captains
8 verified Jersey Shore captains targeting mahi. Every captain has a 4.5+ star rating and direct FishingBooker booking.
Don’t see the right mahi captain?
FishingBooker lists 100+ NJ captains running mahi trips. Browse the full mahi search.
Powered by FishingBooker • Secure online booking • Check cancellation terms
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Captains Targeting Mahi
All 8 verified captains running mahi trips from Jersey Shore ports.
Sligo II
Captain Anthony & KC · Point Pleasant
$650
from
Perfect 5.0 rating. Father-son team brings decades of local experience. Guests rave about their hospitality and fish-finding ability.
Bloody Decks
Captain Team · Point Pleasant
$800
from
Angler's Choice Award for offshore excellence. High-performance Yellowfin built for canyon runs. Premium tackle and experienced crew.
Fin Chaser Sportfishing
Captain Frank Wagenhoffer · Point Pleasant Beach
$900
from
Perfect 5.0 rating across 38 verified trips from Channel Drive. Captain Frank Wagenhoffer runs everything from inshore stripers to canyon tuna.
Sligo Sportfishing
Captain Anthony & KC · Point Pleasant
$900
from
The Sligo team's larger 42-footer, built for offshore and canyon runs — the same father-son crew behind the 5.0-rated Sligo II.
Gone Fishin' Sport Fishing
Captain Team · Cape May
$850
from
Cape May offshore specialists — an Angler's Choice crew with 163 verified reviews chasing tuna, mahi, and tilefish in the canyons.
Moover Fishing Adventures
Captain Rob · Longport
$325
from
Captain Rob's versatile operation, now sailing from Longport minutes from Atlantic City — calm back-bay trips to offshore runs with instant confirmation.
Branarchy
Captain Frank Branagan · Barnegat Light
$675
from
Veteran-owned Barnegat Light operation with a perfect 5.0 across 43 trips — inshore stripers to bluefin with Captain Frank Branagan.
On The Rocks
Captain Jake · Barnegat Light
$400
from
Captain Jake's 31-footer specializes in striper and tuna fishing around Barnegat Inlet — a perfect 5.0 rating with trips from $400.
Mahi Captains by Port
Pick the port closest to where you’re staying — most NJ charter trips leave at sunrise, so a 30-minute drive matters at 4 AM.
Barnegat Light (2 captains)
Cape May (1 captain)
Longport (1 captain)
Point Pleasant (3 captains)
Point Pleasant Beach (1 captain)
Where to Stay for Mahi Trips
Mahi captains run from 5 NJ ports: Barnegat Light, Cape May, Longport, Point Pleasant, Point Pleasant Beach. Pick a hotel within walking distance of the dock so the morning trip starts smoothly.
Hotels & Stays
Find accommodations in Barnegat Light
Flights
Find flights to NJ airports
Car Rentals
Rent a car for your shore trip