🍕 Pizza Spots
in Seaside Heights
Looking for pizza in Seaside Heights? The shore town has 3 spots serving jersey shore pizza from boardwalk slices to artisan pies. Three Brothers From Italy Pizza is a local favorite.
Price Range
1 moderate, 2 budget-friendly
Dining Tip
Jersey Shore pizza is best by the slice. Try a plain cheese slice to judge quality before ordering a whole pie.
3 Pizza Spots in Seaside Heights
Three Brothers From Italy Pizza
Instagram-worthy 24-inch mega slices. Mixed reviews cite staff rudeness and shocking prices ($164 for 4 pies reported), but photos are legendary.
Must Try: 24-inch mega slice
- ✓giant slices
- ✓Instagram-worthy
- ✓boardwalk
Maruca's Tomato Pies
Trenton-style tomato pies since 1950—cheese first, sauce swirled on top. 4.7/5 Google, 7.5/10 from Barstool's Dave Portnoy. Featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.
Must Try: Classic tomato pie
- ✓Trenton-style
- ✓TV famous
- ✓historic
The Sawmill Cafe
"Relatively low-key" late-night slices in Seaside Park. Good for post-bar eating.
Must Try: Late-night slice
- ✓late night
- ✓pizza
- ✓casual
More Dining in Seaside Heights
Pizza Spots at Other Shore Towns
Tips for Pizza Dining in Seaside Heights
Summer reservations: Book 1-2 weeks ahead for weekend dinners, especially July-August.
BYOB advantage: Many Seaside Heights restaurants are BYOB—bring your own wine and save.
Off-peak savings: Early bird specials (5-6pm) often include price breaks.
Dress code: Most pizza spots are casual—flip flops usually fine.
People Also Search For
Pizza Dining FAQs
Stay in Seaside Heights
Book accommodations near the best pizza restaurants in Seaside Heights.
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more