Skip to main content
Jersey ShoreGUIDE
Bar PieTop Pick

Pete & Elda's

Neptune City·$$

The definitive Jersey Shore bar pie experience. Pete & Elda's has been serving impossibly thin, crispy pies since 1950. Expect a wait, but it's absolutely worth it. The Carmen's Special is loaded perfection.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is Pete & Elda's known for?

Pete & Elda's is known for Carmen's Special. The definitive Jersey Shore bar pie experience. Pete & Elda's has been serving impossibly thin, crispy pies since 1950. Expect a wait, but it's absolutely worth it. The Carmen's Special is loaded perfection.

Is Pete & Elda's cash only?

Payment methods are not recorded for Pete & Elda's. Check before visiting.

Does Pete & Elda's sell slices?

Pete & Elda's typically serves whole pies. Call ahead to confirm slice availability.

Must Try

Carmen's Special

What Makes It Special

  • ✓Since 1950
  • ✓Paper-thin bar pie crust
  • ✓BYOB
  • ✓Worth the wait

Features

cash preferredbyobfamily styleno reservations

Advertisement

Insider Tip

Arrive early (before 5pm) or late (after 8:30pm) on weekends. Bring your own beer.

Best For

pizza puristsgroupsdate night

Quick Facts

Location
Neptune City

Monmouth County

Address
96 Woodland Ave, Neptune City, NJ 07753
Price Level
$$
Style
bar pie
Payment
Check with the restaurant

Hours

Summer
Mon-Thu 11am-10pm, Fri-Sat 11am-11pm, Sun 12pm-9pm

No reservations, expect a wait

Where to eat at the Shore, all year

A short series on where to eat, then a Thursday email with the weekend ahead and a planning guide on the 1st.

What interests you? (optional)

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Explore More Pizza Spots

From boardwalk slices to bar pies, find your perfect pizza at the Jersey Shore.