Browse the top pizza places in Belmar with pricing, features, and local tips to help you choose.
Book Belmar Food & Drink Tours
Restaurant crawls, distillery & winery tours, cooking classes. Pair with your dining picks. Free cancellation on most tours.
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more
Local Insight: Pizza Place in Belmar
Pizza Heaven and Reye's Pizza serve classic Jersey slices to the beach crowd. Joe's Pizzeria Restaurant II handles the late-night rush from the bar scene. Expect $3-4 per slice, $18-22 for a whole pie.
What to Look For in Pizza Place
New Jersey takes its pizza seriously, and the shore is no exception. You'll find everything from classic New York-style slices to Trenton tomato pies, Neapolitan wood-fired creations, and boardwalk pizza that hits different at 11pm after a night out. Many shore pizza spots have been serving the same recipes for decades, with lines out the door every summer.
Insider Tips
- Check the crust - it should have character, not be a vehicle for toppings
- Lines usually mean quality, especially for boardwalk spots
- Ask about their sauce - some places have secret family recipes
- Wood-fired ovens produce a different (often superior) crust
Summer Season Tips
Boardwalk slices hit different at night. Expect lines at popular spots. Late-night pizza is a shore tradition.
Top 4 Pizza Places
3 Brothers From Italy
$$Italian seafood restaurant with authentic flavors in Belmar.
Italian Counter
$$Italian counter-service spot in Wall Township outside Belmar.
Pizza Heaven
$$Pizzeria in Belmar.
Reye's Pizza
$$Pizzeria in Belmar.
Our Top Picks Reviewed
Best Overall: 3 Brothers From Italy
3 Brothers From Italy stands out as our top pick for pizza places in Belmar.Italian seafood restaurant with authentic flavors in Belmar. At $$ pricing, it delivers excellent value for the quality. Specializing in seafood and italian, this spot is perfect for both locals and visitors.
Best Value: Pizza Heaven
Pizza Heaven delivers solid quality at $$ pricing.Pizzeria in Belmar. A reliable pick for families and groups on a set budget.
Best for Special Occasions: Italian Counter
For a nicer night out in Belmar, Italian Counter is a strong choice.Italian counter-service spot in Wall Township outside Belmar. The quality and atmosphere hold up well at this price level.
What to Know Before You Go
The pizza places scene in Belmar varies by season. During peak summer months (June through August), wait times at popular spots can exceed an hour, especially on weekend evenings. We recommend making reservations at least a week in advance for weekend dining. Off-season visitors (September through May) will find it much easier to secure tables, and many establishments offer seasonal specials and promotions.
Price-wise, expect to spend between $15-30 per person at $ spots, $30-50 at $$ establishments, $50-80 at $$$ venues, and $80+ at $$$$ fine dining locations. Most Belmar pizza places are BYOB-friendly, which can significantly reduce your total bill if you bring your own wine or beer.
Quick Comparison
| Name | Price | Best For | Highlights |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Brothers From Italy | $$ | Families & Groups | seafood, italian |
| Italian Counter | $$ | Families & Groups | italian |
| Pizza Heaven | $$ | Families & Groups | italian |
| Reye's Pizza | $$ | Families & Groups | italian |
Pizza Place Tips for Value
Get more for your money with these local insights for pizza places in Belmar.
- 1Slices are the cheapest meal at the shore - and often the best
- 2Whole pies are better value than slices if feeding a family
- 3Many places have lunch specials with slice-and-drink combos
- 4Takeout avoids the often minimal seating at popular spots
Planning Your Visit to Belmar?
Check out our complete guide to Belmar with beaches, events, parking info, and more.
View Belmar Guide →Belmar is a diverse, nightlife Monmouth County beach town about 1hr 5min from New York City. Parking, beach badges, events, and the full picture beyond pizza places are in the complete Belmar guide.