Dining in Historic Smithville
Restaurants, seafood, and local favorites in Historic Smithville, New Jersey.
american
Historic Smithville Inn
$$$Fine dining since 1787 in a historic colonial building. Voted "Best Off-Shore Restaurant." Elegant American cuisine with seasonal menus.
Must try: Prime rib or seasonal specials
Fred and Ethel's Lantern Light Tavern
$$Named after Smithville's founders. Casual bar and grill with indoor/outdoor seating, live weekend entertainment, and 8 TVs for sports.
Must try: Homemade French onion soup
cafe
Smithville Bakery
$Famous for homemade doughnuts, custom pies and cakes, and full breakfast menu starting at 7:00 a.m.
Must try: Homemade doughnuts
Colonial Coffee Cafe
$Coffee shop serving specialty drinks, pastries, and light fare. Perfect for a break between shopping.
Must try: Specialty latte
italian
Costello's Italian Ristorante
$$Traditional Italian cuisine in the heart of the village. Family-friendly atmosphere with classic dishes.
Must try: Pasta dishes
casual
Greek Bites
$Quick-service Greek favorites including gyros, souvlaki, and Mediterranean salads.
Must try: Gyro platter