🍕 Pizza Spots
in Seaside Heights
Looking for pizza in Seaside Heights? The shore town has 3 spots serving jersey shore pizza from boardwalk slices to artisan pies. Three Brothers From Italy Pizza is a local favorite.
Price Range
1 moderate, 2 budget-friendly
Dining Tip
Jersey Shore pizza is best by the slice. Try a plain cheese slice to judge quality before ordering a whole pie.
3 Pizza Spots in Seaside Heights
Three Brothers From Italy Pizza
Instagram-worthy 24-inch mega slices. Mixed reviews cite staff rudeness and shocking prices ($164 for 4 pies reported), but photos are legendary.
Must Try: 24-inch mega slice
- ✓giant slices
- ✓Instagram-worthy
- ✓boardwalk
Maruca's Tomato Pies
Trenton-style tomato pies since 1950—cheese first, sauce swirled on top. 4.7/5 Google, 7.5/10 from Barstool's Dave Portnoy. Featured on Diners, Drive-Ins and Dives.
Must Try: Classic tomato pie
- ✓Trenton-style
- ✓TV famous
- ✓historic
The Sawmill Cafe
"Relatively low-key" late-night slices in Seaside Park. Good for post-bar eating.
Must Try: Late-night slice
- ✓late night
- ✓pizza
- ✓casual
More Dining in Seaside Heights
Pizza Spots at Other Shore Towns
Tips for Pizza Dining in Seaside Heights
Summer reservations: Book 1-2 weeks ahead for weekend dinners, especially July-August.
BYOB advantage: Many Seaside Heights restaurants are BYOB—bring your own wine and save.
Off-peak savings: Early bird specials (5-6pm) often include price breaks.
Dress code: Most pizza spots are casual—flip flops usually fine.
People Also Search For
Pizza Dining FAQs
Stay in Seaside Heights
Book accommodations near the best pizza restaurants for a culinary getaway.
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more