NJShore Guide

🍝 Italian Restaurants

in Toms River

Looking for italian in Toms River? The shore town has 22 spots serving pasta, pizza, and authentic italian cuisine. Steverino's Pizza is a local favorite.

Price Range

21 moderate, 1 budget-friendly

Dining Tip

Italian restaurants at the shore often have generous portions. Consider sharing a pasta dish.

22 Italian Restaurants in Toms River

Steverino's Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Sights Of Heaven Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Sal's Italian Rstrnt-Pizzeria

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Rosato Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Rita's Italian Ice-Frozen

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Pizza Hut

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian
211 Route 37 E(732) 341-3883

Pizza & Panini

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Naples Pizza & Restaurant

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Miranda's Midtown Pizza-Ctrng

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Mid-Shore Meats & Italian Deli

$$

Located in Toms River.

italiandeli

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Luigi's Original Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Lisa Restaurant & Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Linda's Pizza On Fischer Blvd

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Johnny G's Italian Restaurant

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Joey D's Brick Oven Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Holiday City Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Dario Pizza Pasta Panini

$$

Italian restaurant serving pizza, pasta, and panini. Located in Toms River.

pizzaitalian

Capone's

$$Reservations

Classic Italian-American dining in a family-friendly atmosphere. Known for generous portions and traditional recipes.

italianamerican

Must Try: Eggplant parmigiana

  • family-friendly
  • Italian classics
  • generous portions

Frankie G's Pizza

$$

Frankie G's Pizza located in Toms River.

pizzaitalian

Geno D's Pizza

$$

Geno D's Pizza located in Toms River.

pizzaitalian

Cuzzins Pizza

$

Casual pizza and Italian cuisine. Located in Toms River.

pizzaitalian

More Dining in Toms River

Italian Restaurants at Other Shore Towns

Tips for Italian Dining in Toms River

Summer reservations: Book 1-2 weeks ahead for weekend dinners, especially July-August.

BYOB advantage: Many Toms River restaurants are BYOB—bring your own wine and save.

Off-peak savings: Early bird specials (5-6pm) often include price breaks.

Dress code: Most italian spots are casual—flip flops usually fine.

People Also Search For

Italian Dining FAQs

Stay in Toms River

Book accommodations near the best italian restaurants for a culinary getaway.

Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more