NJShore Guide

🍝 Italian Restaurants

in Toms River

Looking for italian in Toms River? The shore town has 22 spots serving pasta, pizza, and authentic italian cuisine. Steverino's Pizza is a local favorite.

Price Range

21 moderate, 1 budget-friendly

Dining Tip

Italian restaurants at the shore often have generous portions. Consider sharing a pasta dish.

22 Italian Restaurants in Toms River

Steverino's Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Sights Of Heaven Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Sal's Italian Rstrnt-Pizzeria

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Rosato Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Rita's Italian Ice-Frozen

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Pizza Hut

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian
211 Route 37 E(732) 341-3883

Pizza & Panini

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Naples Pizza & Restaurant

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Miranda's Midtown Pizza-Ctrng

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Mid-Shore Meats & Italian Deli

$$

Located in Toms River.

italiandeli

Mangia Brick Oven Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Luigi's Original Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Lisa Restaurant & Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Linda's Pizza On Fischer Blvd

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Johnny G's Italian Restaurant

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Joey D's Brick Oven Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Holiday City Pizza

$$

Located in Toms River.

italian

Dario Pizza Pasta Panini

$$

Italian restaurant serving pizza, pasta, and panini. Located in Toms River.

pizzaitalian

Capone's

$$Reservations

Classic Italian-American dining in a family-friendly atmosphere. Known for generous portions and traditional recipes.

italianamerican

Must Try: Eggplant parmigiana

  • ✓family-friendly
  • ✓Italian classics
  • ✓generous portions

Frankie G's Pizza

$$

Frankie G's Pizza located in Toms River.

pizzaitalian

Geno D's Pizza

$$

Geno D's Pizza located in Toms River.

pizzaitalian

Cuzzins Pizza

$

Casual pizza and Italian cuisine. Located in Toms River.

pizzaitalian

More Dining in Toms River

🍔 American41 restaurants🌮 Mexican5 restaurants🍕 Pizza6 restaurants🍦 Ice Cream4 restaurants☕ Cafe13 restaurants

Italian Restaurants at Other Shore Towns

Atlantic City (21)Brick Township (18)Asbury Park (14)Point Pleasant Beach (13)Ocean City (11)

Tips for Italian Dining in Toms River

✓

Summer reservations: Book 1-2 weeks ahead for weekend dinners, especially July-August.

✓

BYOB advantage: Many Toms River restaurants are BYOB—bring your own wine and save.

✓

Off-peak savings: Early bird specials (5-6pm) often include price breaks.

✓

Dress code: Most italian spots are casual—flip flops usually fine.

People Also Search For

American in Toms RiverMexican in Toms RiverPizza in Toms RiverBYOB restaurants Toms RiverBest restaurants Toms River

Italian Dining FAQs

Stay in Toms River

Book accommodations near the best italian restaurants in Toms River.

Find HotelsVRBO Vacation Rentals

Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more

← Back to Dining Guide