🍔 American Restaurants
in Cape May
Looking for american in Cape May? The shore town has 21 spots serving classic american comfort food and contemporary dishes. The Ebbitt Room is a local favorite.
Price Range
3 upscale, 1 mid-high, 17 moderate
Dining Tip
Many American restaurants in Cape May offer happy hour specials. Check for early bird dinner deals.
21 American Restaurants in Cape May
The Ebbitt Room
Chef Jason Hanin earned 2025 NJ Chef of the Year. 4.7 stars from 3,500+ OpenTable reviews. Seasonal tasting menus showcase Cape May scallops and Beach Plum Farm ingredients. Elegant porch dining with live piano.
Must Try: Seasonal tasting menu
- ✓award-winning chef
- ✓farm-to-table
- ✓live piano
- ✓porch dining
Washington Inn
4.8 stars from 9,500+ reviews. Most extensive wine selection in Cape May within an 1840 plantation-style building. "Outstanding" baked escargot, seafood risotto, fireside dining. Occasionally noisy on busy nights.
Must Try: Baked escargot
- ✓extensive wine list
- ✓historic building
- ✓fireside dining
Peter Shields Inn
4.8 stars from 7,500+ reviews. Zagat-rated cuisine with direct ocean views from 1907 Georgian Revival setting. NOTE: No longer BYOB as of January 1, 2025 ($40 corkage fee).
Must Try: Chef's tasting menu
- ✓ocean views
- ✓Zagat-rated
- ✓historic inn
410 Bank Street
Chef Sing's Creole-Caribbean cuisine in a vine-covered 1840 carriage house. NY Times called it "the reason many come to Cape May." BYOB. Seasonal closure in winter.
Must Try: Caribbean specialties
- ✓Creole-Caribbean
- ✓BYOB
- ✓historic carriage house
Plumsted Grill
Located in Cream Ridge.
Phinney's Pub
Located in Cape May.
Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant
Located in Cape May.
Oyster Bay Restaurant & Bar
Located in Cape May.
Oceanview Restaurant
Located in Cape May.
Ocean View Family Restaurant
Located in Cape May.
Mermaids Restaurant
Located in Cape May.
Mayer's Tavern
Located in Cape May.
Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar
Located in Cape May.
Lucky Bones Back Water Grille
Located in Cape May.
Harry's Ocean Bar & Grille
Located in Cape May.
Harbor View Restaurant
Located in Cape May.
King Edward Bar
Located in Cape May.
Lucky Bones Backwater Grille
Marina-side praise for fried oysters and Cape May Double IPA craft beer. Family-friendly with outdoor seating.
Must Try: Fried oysters
- ✓waterfront
- ✓happy hour
- ✓kid-friendly
- ✓outdoor seating
The Mad Batter
Operating since 1976 in Victorian Carroll Villa Hotel. Orange & Almond French Toast and famous Bloody Marys. Polarizes visitors—beloved for food, criticized for "supercilious" service. 45-60 minute weekend waits.
Must Try: Orange & Almond French Toast
- ✓Victorian setting
- ✓breakfast famous
- ✓Bloody Marys
George's Place
"If Nancy Meyers opened a Greek diner" atmosphere. Tiramisu waffles and flaming Saganaki draw crowds.
Must Try: Tiramisu waffles or flaming Saganaki
- ✓breakfast
- ✓Greek touches
- ✓Instagram-worthy
The Blue Pig Tavern
Historic tavern at Congress Hall serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Farm-to-table focus with Beach Plum Farm ingredients.
Must Try: Buttermilk pancakes
- ✓historic
- ✓breakfast
- ✓farm-to-table
- ✓patio
More Dining in Cape May
American Restaurants at Other Shore Towns
Tips for American Dining in Cape May
Summer reservations: Book 1-2 weeks ahead for weekend dinners, especially July-August.
BYOB advantage: Many Cape May restaurants are BYOB—bring your own wine and save.
Off-peak savings: Early bird specials (5-6pm) often include price breaks.
Dress code: Most american spots are casual—flip flops usually fine.
People Also Search For
American Dining FAQs
Stay in Cape May
Book accommodations near the best american restaurants in Cape May.
Some links may earn us a commission. Learn more