Best Restaurants in Bay Head
4 hand-picked restaurants in this ocean County beach town
Looking for the best restaurants in Bay Head? We've curated the top spots based on quality, value, and local reputation. From budget-friendly options to upscale experiences, here are our top picks for restaurants in Bay Head.
Top 4 Restaurants
Bay Head Yacht Club
$$$Private club with waterfront dining. Members and guests only—represents the upscale Bay Head lifestyle.
Theresa's
$$$Bay Head's premier restaurant offering refined American cuisine in an elegant Victorian setting. BYOB makes it excellent value for upscale dining.
Nearby Point Pleasant Dining
$$Point Pleasant Beach (5 minutes north) offers more dining options including Red's Lobster Pot, Spike's, and Hoffman's Ice Cream.
Mueller's Bakery
$Family-owned bakery since 1946 serving fresh bread, pastries, and breakfast sandwiches. A Bay Head institution.
Planning Your Visit to Bay Head?
Check out our complete guide to Bay Head with beaches, events, parking info, and more.
View Bay Head Guide →About Bay Head
Bay Head operates on different rules than most shore towns. No boardwalk. No arcades. Minimal commercial development. Instead: Victorian homes dating to the 1880s, pristine beaches backed by dunes rather than development, and an exclusive atmosphere that's been carefully maintained for over a centur...
Why Visit Bay Head?
- upscale atmosphere
- quiet atmosphere
- family atmosphere
- Victorian atmosphere
- exclusive atmosphere
Getting to Bay Head
- From NYC: 1hr 30min
- From Philadelphia: 1hr 30min
- From Newark: 1hr 15min