NJShore Guide

Best Italian Restaurants in Stone Harbor

4 hand-picked italian restaurants in this cape-may County beach town

Looking for the best italian restaurants in Stone Harbor? We've curated the top spots based on quality, value, and local reputation. From budget-friendly options to upscale experiences, here are our top picks for italian restaurants in Stone Harbor.

Top 4 Italian Restaurants

1

Alfredo's Pizza

$$

Classic pizzeria on Magnolia Drive serving New York-style pies and Italian favorites.

pizzaitalian
pizzacasualfamily-friendly
2

Claudio's Pizza Kitchen

$$

Pizza kitchen on South Main Street with Italian specialties and casual beach-town atmosphere.

pizzaitalian
pizzaItaliancasual
3

Mack's Pizza Of Stone Harbor

$$

Located in Stone Harbor.

italian
4

Nemo's Pizza & Italian Cuisine

$$

Located in Stone Harbor.

italian

Planning Your Visit to Stone Harbor?

Check out our complete guide to Stone Harbor with beaches, events, parking info, and more.

View Stone Harbor Guide →

About Stone Harbor

Stone Harbor pairs Seven Mile Island's upscale beach atmosphere with something you won't find anywhere else on the Jersey Shore: genuine nature attractions. The bird sanctuary—America's first municipal bird sanctuary, established 1947—hosts herons, egrets, and ibis within walking distance of the bea...

Why Visit Stone Harbor?

  • family friendly atmosphere
  • nature atmosphere
  • educational atmosphere
  • upscale atmosphere
  • bird watching atmosphere

Getting to Stone Harbor

  • From NYC: 2hr 40min
  • From Philadelphia: 1hr 20min
  • From Newark: 2hr 25min